By: Edward Egros

Biggest Snubs for the Cowboys' Ring of Honor

Pasted Graphic
There was a time when virtually the only way a Dallas Cowboy could make the Ring of Honor was to win a Super Bowl. All but two current members had at least one championship (Don Meredith and Don Perkins). However, this week Cowboys owner Jerry Jones affirmed Tony Romo would be inducted into the Ring of Honor. Not only did the former quarterback fail to reach a Super Bowl, he would be the first Cowboy in franchise history to be inducted without even having won a conference title.

Individually, Romo may not have had stellar a career as Ring of Honorees Troy Aikman or Roger Staubach, but he does surpass the efforts of Meredith, and for being a part of the Cowboys for a dozen years, he likely deserve a place in north Texas immortality. By including Romo, the Cowboys introduce the idea that championships should not be weighted as much when determining who belongs, perhaps opening the door for others.

This idea leads to a question: Who is the most deserving Dallas Cowboy for the Ring of Honor who has yet to make it? One way to evaluate individual performances is with
Approximate Value by Pro Football Reference. The top eight players in Cowboys history have already been inducted, from Emmitt Smith (#1) to Staubach (#8).

The highest Approximate Value not to have his name on the ring is Cornell Green, a cornerback who played for 13 seasons, including for the 1971 Super Bowl team. With 34 interceptions, 171 games started and five Pro Bowl invitations, Green has a better case to make it than anyone else not there, per this metric. His 9th best Approximate Value is better than Aikman, Romo, Lee Roy Jordan, Larry Allen, et al.

Two other players who finish in the Top 20 but who are not in the Ring Honor include Ralph Neely, a left tackle as part of the '71 Super Bowl champions and Nate Newton, the left guard who played during the Cowboys dynasty of the 1990's. While this metric may not be the perfect way to compare players, it does highlight some inconsistency for why some players have already been inducted and why others have had to wait.