By: Edward Egros

Philadelphia

Forced Into Success

Pasted Graphic
(Courtesy: Getty Images)

An odd thing happened to the Dallas Cowboys in their last couple of games: their opponents' starting kickers exited their games early with injuries. Philadelphia's kicker Jake Elliott suffered a head injury and Los Angeles' kicker Nick Novak experienced back problems. Both teams had to resort to emergency backups during the game, with less than ideal results. Each backup was seen missing the practice the net on the sideline while warming up.

The difference between the Eagles and Chargers is how they adjusted to losing their kickers. Philadelphia opted to avoid kicking all together, not attempting field goals and going for two instead of extra point tries. Los Angeles remained conventional, playing as if they had its kicker. The results are drastically different. The Eagles went for 2-point conversions on four occasions, converting three of them. They also faced a fourth-and-5 from the Dallas 17-yard line, scoring a touchdown on the play. Even if you assume Philadelphia would have made that field goal (and every extra point attempt), by not using a kicker, the team gained five points. As for the Chargers, Drew Kaser missed two extra points and still had Novak make one more attempt, which he missed. Had Los Angeles gone for two after all four of its second-half touchdowns, and if we assume they would have converted half of them (the league average), they would have netted three points.

As a result, Los Angeles' conventional wisdom cost them three points, while Philadelphia gained five points with aggressive play calling. In other words, the Eagles were eight points better with their approach.

There is plenty of analytical research suggested NFL teams
kick fewer field goals or attempt more 2-point conversions. While these findings have been perpetually published for years, it hasn't changed the sport very much. Teams are still attempting roughly as many field goals and extra points as ever, even though offenses have improved and extra points have become more difficult. While teams refuse to implement this research, a real life example happened in the span of one week where one team put itself in a better position by kicking less. It doesn't explain everything, but it can spotlight one reason why Philadelphia has the best record in the NFL, while Los Angeles is on the fringe of the playoffs.